# Who Can Sign? Substitute Decision-Makers in Ontario

Somebody has to sign.

That is the question that stops a family cold at the exact moment they have finally agreed on a home. The tour went well, the suite is available, and then a manager slides a thick agreement across the table and asks who is signing it.

Ontario already answered that question. Not warmly, not conveniently, but clearly. There is a rule about who decides, and it does not turn on who is loudest, who lives closest, or who found the home.

Here is the rule, which of the two documents in your parent's file actually applies, and what happens when nobody holds either one.

## Who decides when a parent moves into care in Ontario

### Who decides if your parent still has capacity?

A parent who is mentally capable of making this particular decision makes it themselves, and no attorney, adult child or home can override them. Ontario treats capacity as [specific to the decision in front of the person](https://www.ontario.ca/page/mental-capacity), not as a single switch that is on or off.

That distinction does real work. Someone can be incapable of managing an investment account and perfectly capable of deciding where they want to live. Ontario's own guidance is that a person is incapable of a decision when they cannot understand the information relevant to it, or cannot appreciate what happens if they make it or refuse it.

Capacity is also assessed at a moment in time. It can come and go, and it can be regained.

So the first question is never "who has the power of attorney." It is "has anyone actually established that Mum cannot make this decision?"

### What is a substitute decision-maker in Ontario?

A substitute decision-maker is the person Ontario law authorises to make a decision on behalf of someone who is not mentally capable of making it themselves. The role only activates once incapacity for that decision has been established.

A substitute decision-maker is not a proxy for the family's preference. Under the framework described by [CLEO's plain-language guide to powers of attorney for personal care](https://www.cleo.on.ca/en/publications/power/all), the decision-maker must follow the person's most recent capable wishes, and only where those are unknown or impossible to follow may they decide on best interests.

That is a narrower job than most families expect. The question is not "what would we prefer for Dad." It is "what did Dad say, while he could still say it."

### What is the ranked list if there is no power of attorney?

Ontario does not leave the question open when no power of attorney exists: the [Health Care Consent Act, 1996](https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/96h02) sets an order of priority, and the highest-ranked person who is willing, able and legally permitted becomes the decision-maker.

CLEO sets out that statutory order as: a court-appointed guardian of the person; then an attorney under a power of attorney for personal care; then a representative appointed by the Consent and Capacity Board; then a spouse or partner; then a parent or child; then a sibling; then any other relative; and finally the Office of the Public Guardian and Trustee.

Read that list slowly, because it contains the sentence most families do not want to hear. Adult children rank *below* a spouse, and rank *equally* with each other. Three siblings who disagree do not have a tiebreaker built into the statute.

The list also cannot be reordered by agreement, by geography, or by who has been doing the caregiving.

## Two different powers of attorney

### What does a power of attorney for personal care cover?

A power of attorney for personal care lets a named person make decisions about health, housing and daily life once the grantor is no longer capable of making them. CLEO describes the territory as where you live, what you eat, what you wear, washing and bathing, and keeping you safe.

Where you live. That is the phrase that matters for this decision.

To make one in Ontario a person must be at least 16, must understand what they are doing, and must sign in front of two witnesses. It is not a court process and it does not require a lawyer, though ACE and most lawyers will tell you that a badly drafted one causes more trouble than no document at all.

### What does a power of attorney for property cover instead?

A continuing power of attorney for property covers money (bank accounts, income, bills, and the management of assets), and it does not carry authority over personal care decisions. Ontario's own [guardianship guidance](https://www.ontario.ca/page/guardianship) draws the same line for court-appointed guardians: a guardian of property makes financial decisions and cannot make personal care or health care decisions.

Two documents. Two domains. Most families have one and assume it covers both.

| | Power of attorney for personal care | Continuing power of attorney for property |
|---|---|---|
| What it covers | Health care, housing, meals, clothing, hygiene, safety | Bank accounts, income, bills, assets, property |
| When it starts | On incapacity for the decision in question | Can be effective while the grantor is still capable |
| Governing statute | [Substitute Decisions Act, 1992](https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/92s30) and the [Health Care Consent Act, 1996](https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/96h02) | [Substitute Decisions Act, 1992](https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/92s30) |
| Court-appointed equivalent | Guardian of the person | Guardian of property |

The table's practical conclusion is that neither document is a general-purpose licence to act for a parent: each one answers a different half of the move, and a family holding only one of them is holding half the authority they think they have.

### Which document lets someone sign a residency agreement?

A retirement home residency agreement is both a tenancy contract and a care contract, so it sits across both kinds of authority at once, which is why homes commonly ask to see both documents rather than one. The care and housing side is personal care territory; the payment obligation is property territory.

This is the point where general information stops being enough. Whether a given agreement can be validly signed by a given attorney depends on the wording of that document and that contract, and no article can read either one.

Get it checked. [The Advocacy Centre for the Elderly](https://www.acelaw.ca/legal-topic/retirement-homes/) is a legal clinic for low-income Ontario seniors and publishes on exactly this, and a lawyer can answer it in a single appointment. Reading the [residency agreement itself with fresh eyes](/blog/retirement-home-residency-agreement-ontario) before anyone signs is the cheaper half of the same task.

## When it goes wrong

### What happens when the family disagrees with the decision-maker?

Disagreement does not transfer the authority. The person who ranks highest on the statutory list still decides, and the rest of the family's role becomes advising rather than deciding. That is uncomfortable, and it is also the point of having a rule.

Where the objection is that the decision-maker is not acting on the person's known wishes, that is a different and more serious complaint than "we would have chosen differently." The [Office of the Public Guardian and Trustee](https://www.ontario.ca/page/guardianship) investigates where someone may be incapable and at risk of serious harm and no alternative solution is available.

If the argument is really about the move rather than the authority, working through a sibling disagreement about a parent's care is the more useful place to start, and if the conversation with your parent has not happened yet, [how to raise senior living with a parent](/blog/how-to-talk-to-parent-about-senior-living).

### Who decides if no substitute decision-maker is willing or able?

The Office of the Public Guardian and Trustee is the decision-maker of last resort in Ontario when nobody higher on the list is available, willing and able to act. It sits at the bottom of the statutory order precisely so the list never runs out.

Families can also apply to the Superior Court of Justice to be appointed guardian of the person, of property, or both. It is slower and more expensive than a power of attorney signed while a parent was still capable, which is the argument for doing the paperwork early, while a parent can still choose who signs.

Whatever happens, the [Residents' Bill of Rights](https://www.rhra.ca/en/information-for-retirement-home-residents/residents-bill-of-rights/) applies to your parent in a licensed Ontario retirement home no matter who signed the agreement, including the right to know what care services cost and to participate in care planning.

## What this changes about choosing a home

Every licensed community in the Agewise coverage area is listed. Agewise is not paid a referral fee when a family moves in. No operator can buy a position, and no plan buys one sideways either. The ranking never reads how recently a listing was updated. It reads what a listing answers. Answering more of it is free. Sorting out who can sign delays a move-in. Nothing in our revenue is attached to that timing, so this page can say: stop, and sort out the paperwork first.

This article is general information, not medical, legal, or financial advice. Capacity, authority and contract terms vary by person and by document. Confirm specifics with a lawyer, the Advocacy Centre for the Elderly, or the relevant government body before signing anything.

Sorting out who can sign is not a detour from the search. It is the part that makes the rest of it real. Agewise helps families compare senior living options across Canada, and Avery, our free guide, can help you get the questions straight before you sit down at that table.